Demonstrating Their Ignorance
Wednesday, June 30th, 2010
Imagine if the Ontario unions which demonstrated futilely in Toronto, on the weekend, had put their efforts into fighting the HST. Imagine if they had logically demonstrated in those countries which need “human rights, dignity…and a fair wage.”
I’m not surprised to hear that my union dues were spent to bus members to the G8/G20 demonstrations. Nor would I be surprised that few of the riders were clear on the issues they were defending. However, a union spokesman questioned by the local CBC radio station, was sufficiently clear on the issues that supposedly motivated the participants to go to Toronto – “…a living wage, dignity, human rights…”. But above all, the constant threat to relatively wealthy unions, posed by impossibly low-wage competitors.
This issue has been at the core of summit protests. Global leaders epitomize global competition and “multinational corporations”. Globalization means having to outbid a competition that is willing to settle for the proverbial bowl-of-rice-a-day. Nothing new here, unions are still fighting the free trade fight, and doing so with a finger in a dam.
In the aftermath of enormous turmoil in the bankruptcy of most of the domestic auto industry, one would expect unions to be clearer on the motivations of corporations. The need for lower costs is a more logical explanation for globalization, than just greed and meanness. In fact, the unions play a large part in that need. So when they vilify impoverished third world workers, who are hungry to accept our jobs for less, how does that square with unions’ stated goals of dignity, human rights, fair wages? Are those things the proprietary goals of only western workers?
Let me assure you that I am not anxious to watch my wages fall just to do the world a good turn. There are less futile ways. Low wage countries will be less threatening when we have learned to diminish their advantage difference, rather than shutting our trade walls. One way to ease that difference is by fighting higher taxation so that we can keep what we earn. By having given the HST the reaction it needed. But we have barely heard a peep from unions on that subject. That is so because they are unclear on the concept of wealth creation. There is no tax, unions don’t love, especially public sector unions who depend on them for the gravy train ride McGuinty has given them. It is hard to keep that finger in the dam, while reaching for more.